R.E.M. has enjoyed success that is not typical of their brand of “nerd” or “college” rock. Though they began over 20 years ago with the album Murmur (1983), R.E.M. exploded into the mainstream with Out of Time (1991) single “Losing My Religion.” R.E.M.’s early 90’s period has the hallmarks of the band’s career. While Out of Time made R.E.M. famous, Automatic for the People made them a legacy.
R.E.M.’s Automatic for the People (1992) was their 8th studio album release and is to this date one of their most successful, selling over four million copies. Featuring lead singer Peter Stipe, guitarist Peter Buck, bassist Mike Mills, and (now former) drummer Bill Berry, the album features twelve tracks devoted to a range of topics from death (“Everybody Hurts,” “Try Not to Breathe”) to skinnydipping (“Nightswimming”).
Far from an upbeat album, it has its moments of sunshiny goodness: “Sidewinder Sleeps Tonight” is bouncy and bright (although it does tend to push Stipe to the limit of his vocal range), and the famous tribute to Andy Kaufman “Man on the Moon” is a bit more upbeat and well-received. However, it becomes clear very quickly that this is not the mood the band was going for, as both songs are placed on far sides of the album from each other, separated by songs like the hit anti-suicide anthem “Everybody Hurts,” the somber melodic guitar-and-orchestra piece “Sweetness Follows,” and the droning hums and interspersed guitar of “Star Me Kitten.”
Though it doesn’t stay true to it, Automatic is at least mainly about death. It certainly does not back away from dark lyrics and heavy orchestra arrangements that drag the music into an almost hypnotic depressive state – but, impressively, it does it in a good way. It doesn’t hurt that orchestra arrangements by Led Zeppelin bassist John Paul Jones are on quite a few of the tracks. Without these, it would have been too easy to have empty sad undistinguished music versus the full soothing melancholy it achieves.
And here, fifteen years later, the album proves to be as timeless as it could possibly hope to be. Relevant, heart-wrenching, and lovely, it may be a treasure of acquired taste, but it is a treasure nonetheless. That’s why when my copy became too scratched from hours upon hours of playtime, I bought it again. It is more than a mainstay – it is essential.

Stumble It!


14 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 7, 2007 at 10:55 pm
W.E.B. Adamant
My intent with reviewing Automatic for the People was to bring back an album I know many in my age group aren’t familiar with and by many is only remembered for “Man on the Moon” and “Everybody Hurts.” An exploration of death and loss (not necessarily the same thing), I think it’s important for people to be aware of albums that they can relate to, as well as point to a different R.E.M. that isn’t so radio friendly.
March 8, 2007 at 8:21 pm
Bargain Game Hunter
I loved Automatic for the People. It really is the height of REM’s greatness. With songs like Drive and Ignoreland, they really kicked it up a notch, combining rock with some great melodies. Experimental, but still accessible, amazing album.
March 8, 2007 at 11:14 pm
jsoliver
You think “Everybody Hurts” is what sold the album? I’m not saying the rest of it isn’t good, but that seems to be the one song on it that everybody on the planet wants to hear. Just saying…
March 9, 2007 at 12:12 am
snookju
You keep a very good tone of voice throughout this piece. Nice setup, good observations, and tastefully restrained relation to your own experience. I don’t know what more I could ask for out of this review.
R.E.M. entered my life my junior year of high school, when Dr. “Hutch” and Dr. Baker (a former Honors College professor) used it in conjunction with “The Scarlet Letter” as a song to understand the mentality of Dimmesdale. Now, I can’t break R.E.M. out of that context, and it will always be precious to me.
March 12, 2007 at 2:01 am
jsoliver
Okay, so this comment is just a response to what you wrote on my Beatles article (but it’s a conversation after all, right?) and I just wanted to say that I whole-heartedly agree about the early years. Post ‘67 was better music that I like more, but I still love that the “Hard Day’s Night” era. Maybe it was just pop, but it was damn good pop.
March 12, 2007 at 7:43 pm
rawra
Nice conclusion! I had to write an essay on an American history test comparing R.E.M.’s “Losing My Religion” and …uh….something historic. Anyway, I have great respect for R.E.M. , and your post was lovely.
March 13, 2007 at 1:41 pm
ularaannepage
I had listened to REM growing up. You pretty much got them right. I hadn’t really paid that much attention to the lyrics, but I agree with you that they are mainly about death. How cool!!!
March 13, 2007 at 9:36 pm
Donna B.
Lovely review — the short word count kept you focused on the album itself. You gave good examples of the songs on the album, described them creatively and accurately, and put it in historical context. The matter is far more complex than you probably had space, knowledge, or inclination to essay, but I can’t fault your diction or insight. For a different view, see this blog post on the A.V. Club that questions whether R.E.M.’s later period has diminished even their earlier works to irrelevancy.
March 14, 2007 at 8:40 pm
thesimmons
As always Whit…you make my review look bad. Thanks
.
And thank you Micheal Stipe for making spinning in circles all spaz-like a dance. You da man.
March 15, 2007 at 4:09 am
grubbenator
Nice review. I like that you added that the album was about death and that you made sure to note the upbeat songs. People often see REM as depressing so it nice to know that they do have up beat songs even if they talk about death….a lot. Great Job!
March 19, 2007 at 2:43 pm
Sarah
Oh, I really liked this review too. I think you might have found your calling with album reviews… will you deliver as well with movies? We will have to see.
I am a fan of radio R.E.M. I’ve never seeked them out beyond that, but I like that if I did, I would know what to look for. Well-rounded review.
August 2, 2007 at 1:12 pm
adultmedia
Very nice site.
August 12, 2007 at 2:52 pm
Patrick
They sold over 15million copies from “Automatic for the People”
October 24, 2007 at 3:47 am
Irwan
***** i guess…
the best R.E.M album, find the river and man on the moon is my favorite